
Editorâs note: ISIS has taken responsibility for Tuesdayâs explosions at an airport and a metro station in Brussels that killed 34 people and injured more than 200. It is the latest claim in a wave of terrorism since ISIS began its deadly assaults outside of Syria and Iraq.
UNH Today spoke with UNH Manchester'sÌęhomeland security expert Jim Ramsay, professor of security studies, and Melinda NegrĂłn-Gonzales, assistant professor of politics and society, about the recent attacks.
Ìę
When Jim Ramsay walked into his classroom at UNH Manchester Tuesday morning, he set aside his planned lesson and asked students to talk about the terrorist attacks in Brussels.
What does your gut tell you? Whatâs going on? That's what Ramsay, a professor of security studies and a leading authority on homeland security education, asked his students. He was, he says, trying to create perspective, noting, âBad guys have always been on the planet.â
And thatâs true. The word terrorism, meaning to use violence or intimidation to further a political, religious or ideological goal, was first recorded during Franceâs Reign of Terror in the late 1700s when more than 16,000 people were beheaded. In recent years, the strategy â if thatâs what it is â has still employed that barbaric act as well as mass bombings and suicide bombings.Ìę
âThere was obviously a lot of frustration and anger. Everyone asked âWhy?ââ Ramsay says of studentsâ reaction to the killings in Belgium. âBut thatâs an illogical question because itâs predicated by a groupâs trumped-up ideology â theyâre using God as an excuse for what theyâre doing when maybe the answer is just that there are people who want to see the world burn.â
Melinda NegrĂłn-Gonzales, assistant professor of politics and society and coordinator of the politics and society program at UNH Manchester, puts it another way, suggesting maybe it has nothing to do with religion. Maybe the weight of feeling disenfranchised, of feeling they have no voice, no power, has led people to join these groups that offer them a place to belong.
âWe know that a fair number of people drawn to ISIS are not particularly religious. There is a theory out there that a lot of these people are sort of drifters, or second and third generation immigrants who feel they arenât being treated fairly. People become radicalized because they are looking for a place to vent their anger,â says NegrĂłn-Gonzales, who teaches the class Political Violence & Terrorism. Ìę
âScholars of terrorism are less focused on ideology than the root causes â what lets someone be susceptible. People want to belong to an important group. There is something missing in their life so they want to become someone, become a leader â especially young men who become empowered by joining groups. They lose sight of religion. Itâs about feeling manly.â
And those feelings arenât something that will change by carpet bombingÌęISIS or closing our borders to Muslim immigrants, the professors say.
âWe are a nation of immigrants. You canât turn back the clock. You donât fight a global threat by becoming isolationists,â Ramsay says. âWe need to do exactly what world leaders did in response to this recent attack. We need to stand united; we need to join forces; we need to be together on this.â
âHow we fight them is to make them less relevant,â he adds. âYou have these people who donât have anything to do, who canât feed their families, who are suffering from shortages, who are armed, and they go and do what we would do if we didnât have food or jobs â they join an organization they think will do something about it.â
It is exactly that thinking that needs to come into play as governments try to find a way to combat terrorism, NegrĂłn-Gonzales says.
âEven if the U.S. and its allies launched an effective, successful attack, we would still need to dismantle the jihadist network. Even if ISIS was militarily defeated in Syria, there are already terrorist cells in Europe and the U.S. that can continue to exist,â NegrĂłn-Gonzales says.
To stress that point with her students, NegrĂłn-Gonzales uses counterterrorism exercises that provide a multipronged approach to the problem to help them understand that military action alone isnât the answer.
âA solution has to entail a lot more. It needs to include working with a variety of communities, targeting at-risk youth before they become radicalized, working with youth in prisons â we know that some of the French jihadists had spent time in jail â all that needs to be dealt with,âÌę NegrĂłn-Gonzales says. âEven people whose jobs are to keep America safe 24 hours a day know it will take more than just military action.â
Ramsay says using a human security approach that focuses on providing people with food security and environmental security could help make extremist groups less compelling to potential recruits.
âIf more people had the ability to feed their family, to work, to be engaged, to live a life, more people would see the bad guys as less relevant. They wouldnât need to join those groups because theyâd have their own structure,â he says, adding, âWe canât make terrorism disappear. Thereâs no victory lap here.â
And while it appears that the timing of Tuesday's deadly explosions could be tied to the recent arrest of Salah Abdeslam, a prime suspectÌęin the November terrorist attacks in Paris, Ramsay says it also could have been unrelated.
âI would guess there are a variety of groups in world that have a plan in their back pocket, and when it suits them to strike, they do,â Ramsay says. âIt could have been in their back pocket, and they were looking for a reason. Or it could be someone woke up Tuesday and said âtodayâs the day.ââ
-
Written By:
Jody Record â95 | Communications and Public Affairs | jody.record@unh.edu